Topic on Extension talk:LDAPAuthorization

Battling with these extensions and have got Authorization to work, but when I try to restrict by group it fail. Looking at function makeGroupRequirements the ldapUserGroups has no values.

   $ldapUserGroups = $this->ldapClient->getUserGroups( $username );

$username equals "andrew" and looking at debug output the memberof has been read.

[MediaWiki\Extension\LDAPProvider\Client] MediaWiki\Extension\LDAPProvider\Client::getUserDN: search with array (

  'base' => 'dc=dcs,dc=bbk,dc=ac,dc=uk',

  'filter' => '(samaccountname=andrew)',

  'attributes' =>

  array (

   0 => '*',

   1 => 'memberof',

  ),

)

....

   10 => 'usncreated',

   'memberof' =>

   array (

     'count' => 7,

     0 => 'CN=xxx1,DC=dcs,DC=bbk,DC=ac,DC=uk',

     1 => 'CN=xxx2,DC=dcs,DC=bbk,DC=ac,DC=uk',

     2 => 'CN=xxx3,OU=StaffUsers,DC=dcs,DC=bbk,DC=ac,DC=uk',

     3 => 'CN=xxx4,OU=StaffUsers,DC=dcs,DC=bbk,DC=ac,DC=uk',

     4 => 'CN=xxx5,CN=Users,DC=dcs,DC=bbk,DC=ac,DC=uk',

     5 => 'CN=xxx6,CN=Users,DC=dcs,DC=bbk,DC=ac,DC=uk',

     6 => 'CN=xxx7,OU=StaffUsers,DC=dcs,DC=bbk,DC=ac,DC=uk',

   ),

   11 => 'memberof',

   'usnchanged' =>

   array (

     'count' => 1,

Any ideas?

Maybe you need to set <code>"MediaWiki\\Extension\\LDAPProvider\\UserGroupsRequest\\UserMemberOf::factory"</code> in you domain config under "connection/grouprequest". See Extension:LDAPProvider#Domain_config_settings

@Osnard GREAT!!! That worked.

I have this problem with OpenLDAP and "MediaWiki\\Extension\\LDAPProvider\\UserGroupsRequest\\GroupMember::factory" - The group I want to search is a 'groupOfNames'

Without the authorization plugin enabled I can log in.

The config in a json file: {

       "LDAP": {
               "connection": {
                       "server": "XXX",
                       "user": "cn=docswiki_ro,ou=serviceaccounts,dc=XXX",
                       "pass": "",
                       "basedn": "XXX",
                       "groupbasedn": "ou=roles,ou=groups,dc=XXX",
                       "userbasedn": "ou=volunteers,dc=XXX",
                       "searchattribute": "uid",
                       "searchstring": "uid=USER-NAME,ou=volunteers,dc=XXX",
                       "usernameattribute": "uid",
                       "realnameattribute": "cn",
                       "emailattribute": "mail",
                       "grouprequest": "MediaWiki\\Extension\\LDAPProvider\\UserGroupsRequest\\GroupMember::factory"
               },
               "authorization": {
                       "rules": {
                               "groups": {
                                       "required": [
                                               "cn=rol_webadmin,ou=roles,ou=groups,dc=XXX"
                                       ]
                               }
                       }
               }
       }

}

You may need to "hack" that code line until I can introduce a proper configuration variable: https://github.com/wikimedia/mediawiki-extensions-LDAPProvider/blob/5c4546b8cb1f9890c3063f0bf073793e66563c01/src/UserGroupsRequest/GroupMember.php#L31

Alternatively you can implement a `UserGroupsRequest` class yourself and contribute it.

I think I see the problem. I'm using an objectclass 'groupofnames' (in openldap) but the code you added only checks for a 'group.' When I have time I'll change that in the code and see if it works.

Confirmed, I changed it into groupOfNames and now my account authorizes but my test account doesn't; as expected.

Thanks for confirming this. I have added this topic to https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T214146

It's working??

I have this problem, too. But it only occurs in private wikis. What can I do to solve this?

I use MediaWiki 1.39.3

PHP Version 8.1.2

MariaDB 10.6.12

Which LDAP extension versions are you using?

I'm using

PluggableAuth 5.7

LDAPAuthentication2 1.0.3

LDAPProvider 1.0.5

LDAPUserInfo 1.0.0

LDAPAuthorization 1.1.0

I cannot use PluggableAuth 6.X since it doesn't work with LDAPAuthentication2 or LDAPAuthorization yet.

The change has been merged quite a while ago. You can now set the groupobjectclass to groupOfNames in connection.