Topic on Talk:ORES review tool

Like the tool. But I am , seeing about a third of the revisions flagged in my recent changes as good faith, and for the most part good, changes to the articles from IPs. Is there any chance we could do two things:

First, since the work is not garunteed bad, but very likely to be damaging: can we please include the confidence in the edit as damaging -- as someone who would like to help refine the model, it would be rewarding to be able to give feedback on individual instances when I feel like the machine is very, very far off in prediction.

Secondly, the red in my watchlist screams "red alert!" big problem! Lots of likilhood of it being terrible" Wheras my experience so far has been more in a warmer colour (orange, or something), where the change is of need for attention but not screaming at me.

This is a solid feature request. It's something we have thought about a lot, but we didn't have a phab task for it, so I made one. See Phab:T144922.

The biggest reason we don't have this yet is that working within MediaWiki is really tricky. The ORES extension is largely based off of ScoredRevisions, which does implement this confidence-based coloring and tooltips. The gadget can much more easily modify the visual representation of the RC Feed without worrying about the underlying complexity. We have different constraints with the extension.

Brilliant! And thank you for the context!ft Nd that

User:I wanted to help not hurt since 2011 I just created this account 2016, thanks for your feedback. We definitely don't intend for ORES to be flagging these edits. In all honesty, ORES doesn't have a good grasp on neutrality yet. But it would be good to have some examples of the kind of edits you are talking about for our tests. Could you give a few examples?

@I wanted to help not hurt since 2011 I just created this account 2016

-Super Personal Backstory...Check

-Something about not doing anything this year, but in previous..Check

I just don't understand the point behind this, EpochFail never said anything to trigger this...so this happened.

It's merged and deployed to the second group of wikis (All websites except Wikipedia). So you can see the result in Wikidata. (You need to enable ORES as a beta feature). It'll go to English Wikipedia tomorrow.

Sadads see ^. Thanks for your post about this issue.

@EpochFail & @Ladsgroup Thats brilliant! Thanks for the ping! That colour is much healthier (waiting for the enwiki deploy :D)