Proton

Proton allows users to download a Wikipedia article as PDF. It supports both desktop and mobile-friendly prints.

Proton

Generate PDF version of any Wikipedia Article

Group:	Readers
Start:	2018-12
Backlog:	#Proton

Technical details

edit

Proton is a simple service that generates the PDF using Chromium driven by Puppeteer library. It consists of two components:

Queue system that queues all requests (as PDF generation is both resource and time-intensive job)
Renderer code which instructs Puppeteer to print requested page as PDF.

Proton is structured as a web service and is written in JavaScript, making use of Node.js. It is intended to provide beautiful and clean PDFs. On Wikimedia wikis, Proton will be proxied behind RESTBase. It uses the puppeteer-core library, chromium browser is not bundled with puppeteer-core and it has to be downloaded separately. The PUPPETEER_EXECUTABLE_PATH environment variable is used to point to chromium executable.

The best way to generate the Article PDF is to use browser built-in to PDF functionality. That method provides the best results and additionally allows us to reuse the existing print styles available for both Desktop and Mobile versions of Wikipedia. The system doesn't post-process the requested HTML. Articles are printed the same way as they appear in print preview in the user browser. The generated PDFs are very similar (if not identical) to what anyone can achieve by using Print to PDF on their Chrome browser. To get best results, Proton disables the JavaScript. It is done to disable all dynamic content transformations, like lazy-loaded images on Mobile pages.

Note: for some users, the PDF they get from browser print and the one they get from Proton service might differ a bit as fonts configuration on user system can have specific settings related to fonts hinting/kerning.

QueueSystem

edit

The Queue system is the heart of Proton renderer. It handles the flow of each job through waiting/processing/timeout logic. Each job in the queue can have two states - waiting and processing. The queue system not only allows a specific amount of jobs to run at the same time but it also handles job timeouts and job cancellation. Because of the queue complexity, we had to implement the solution that allows us to:

limit the number of waiting jobs
after a defined amount of seconds reject the waiting job
limit the number of rendering jobs (as PDF rendering requires lots of resources)
a safety net to reject rendering jobs that takes too much time
to save resources, when the request is aborted queue will try to cancel the job, doesn't matter which state the aborted job is (processing/rendering).

The queue system is based on Bluebird promises, and utilizes the cancellation feature (about which see #Known hacks below).

Renderer

edit

The Renderer is a simple facade to access page.pdf() method from puppeteer library. Renderer is responsible for setting proper chromium environment and browser viewport, requesting the Wikipedia page, calling the page.pdf() function. Plus it keeps an eye on the browser process. Each render starts new Chromium instance, and after successful render, the chromium process exits. To save resources, and keep our system in good state Renderer asks Chromium to shut down and if because of any reason browser still keeps processing the request it will send the SIGKILL to browser process to make sure it doesn't use any more CPU nor the memory.

Additional features

edit

When a job fails because the queue is full or job timeouts in any state the Proton service will return 503 Service Unavailable response with Retry-After header. The Retry-After header instruments load balancer to depool given Proton node so it can finish processing current jobs. System sets Retry-After header to app.config.render_queue_timeout configuration value. After that time all processing jobs should finish, and the system should be able to pick up new jobs.

Known hacks

edit

Proton utilizes the BBPromise cancellation feature. Cancellation feature is disabled by default, to enable promise cancellation BBPromise.config() has to be called with cancellation:true flag. The trick is that the BBPromise config has to be set before any promise is created. But because Proton uses the Service-runner, and Service-runner uses BBPromises for everything, even reading configuration files this wasn't easy to implement. The cancellation flag cannot be set in the Proton application, because the Proton code is executed after Service-runner initialization. It also couldn't be defined in config, as Service-runner uses promises when reading the config. In version 2.6.6 of Service-runner introduces use of the APP_ENABLE_CANCELLABLE_PROMISES environment variable, which has to be set to truthy value. If the environment variable is not set, Proton initialization will fail with error.

In order to support a wide variety of languages its suggested to install the following fonts in the deployment:

fonts-liberation
fonts-noto
fonts-noto-cjk
fonts-noto-cjk-extra
fonts-noto-color-emoji
fonts-noto-extra
fonts-noto-mono
fonts-noto-ui-core
fonts-noto-ui-extra
fonts-noto-unhinted

Development

edit

Development happens in the Proton service Git repository. Code review happens in Gerrit. See Getting started to set up an account for yourself. Service uses the ServiceTemplateNode project template and follows all Service development rules.

Running the tests

edit

To run all swagger tests and mocha tests:

npm test

To run all coverage tests:

npm run coverage

Technical documents

edit

README.md has the documentation about Proton internals and configuration variables.
Kubernetes deployment How to deploy Proton (for example) service
Reading/Web/Projects/Print Styles - Print styles and limitations are identical to Browser print styles.