Parsoid/Parser Unification/Confidence Framework/Pixel Diff Results/Diffs

Abbreviation keys

edit

Diffs from 1.43.0-wmf.24

edit

Diffs for jawikivoyage

edit

This list includes a CSS-only fix that might need to be applied on wiki but which has been factored into the visual diffing framework. This list also relies on normalization of p-br HTML where the br is normalized away to remove vertical whitespace diffs that introduce a lot of noise. Together these adaptations expose other bigger issues that might need to be fixed.

Diff score Diff Link Blocker Phab task Remarks
4018 鹿児島市 N Table-width issue on the second table at the bottom of the page
3037 旅の話題 N randomized element in the middle of the page; false positive
3009 管理者伝言板 N different centering of banner image (false positive on the screenshot, the rendered pages are fine)
2024 安芸太田町 N? Missing a new line before the population graphs - might be fixed by adding it in the Wikitext
2021 ルート66 N VWS
1038 ハレ N Link difference; Parsoid output is better
1038 N? Missing a new line at the beginning of the second section
1035 バチカン市国 N Top notice is rendered better in Parsoid; different font size in the bottom banner (but Parsoid avoids a two-character line, which could admittedly be better)
1033 南ロシア N VWS
1032 南牧村_(群馬県) N Table-width issue on the table at the bottom of the page
1030 富士市 N VWS
1002 空港コード N Bottom notice is rendered better in Parsoid
1001 南欧 N Rendering difference in Kartographer error message ("<maplink>" vs "maplink") - easy to fix but non-critical

Diffs for dewikivoyage

edit
Diff score Diff Link Blocker Phab task Remarks
23035 Ereignisse_in_Sabah_Juli_2012 Y T373776 noinclude issue
19031 Ereignisse_in_Sabah_April_2013 Y T373776 noinclude issue
17033 Ereignisse_in_Sabah_März_2013 Y T373776 noinclude issue
14035 Ereignisse_in_Malaysia_Mai_2013 Y T373776 noinclude issue
11026 Badeplätze_in_der_Oberlausitz N Gallery rendering diff: different alignment + legacy has captions and parsoid doesn't

Follow-up: They both have captions but Parsoid's are displayed as in the requested mode, packed hover. The legacy parser has dropped the opening unordered list tag and been subsumed by the preceding list. Parsoid's output is closer to the intention of the author, which is trying to include a gallery in a list, which doesn't really work in the legacy parser. See https://de.wikivoyage.org/w/index.php?title=Badepl%C3%A4tze_in_der_Oberlausitz&diff=1525046&oldid=1525036

Fixed with https://de.wikivoyage.org/w/index.php?title=Badepl%C3%A4tze_in_der_Oberlausitz&diff=1645834&oldid=1541706

2038 Reisen_mit_dem_Zug_in_der_Ukraine N Newline issue at template boundary
2002 Ponta_Delgada N T371916 Missing an image (the windmill) in the gallery at the bottom
2001 Frachtschiffreise N Image not loading, false positive
2000 Norddeutschland Differences in coordinates in the top coordinates (more than a rounding error); extra section edit link in Parsoid (that leads to error) + image not loading)
1040 Coney_Island N? Partial breadcrumb trail on Parsoid
1040 Manhattan/Bowery N? Partial breadcrumb trail on Parsoid
1036 Internationale_Sport-Ereignisse/Archiv N? Missing breadcrumb trail on Parsoid
1036 Südamerika/Ländertabelle N? Missing breadcrumb trail on Parsoid
1034 Wien_Westbahnhof N VWS
1022 Bergen_(Norwegen) N VWS
1021 Metz_Nancy_Lothringen N VWS
1020 Ringlet N VWS
1019 Hama maybe? extra section edit link in Parsoid (that leads to an error)
1018 Schlatt_ZH N VWS
1018 Marradi N VWS
1017 Argentière N Minor differences in table renderings
1017 Gülsehir N? task T376143 Rounding difference in the coordinates in the indicator + VWS
1004 Union_City_(Kalifornien) N Parsoid links a category link that legacy doesn't (better rendering)
1003 Kurische_Nehrung maybe? TC + extra section edit link in Parsoid (that leads to an error)
1003 Morskoje redirection to Kurische Nehrung
1001 Friedenfels N Parsoid images are slighly less wide

Fixed by https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/c/mediawiki/services/parsoid/+/1077118

Diffs from 1.43.0-wmf.26

edit

Diffs for dagwiki

edit
Diff score Diff Link Blocker Phab task Remarks
1036 List_of_awards_and_nominations_received_by_Miley_Cyrus Y? citation issues + INVESTIGATE CSS not applying for one of the table's borders.
1035 Dolly_Parton_ni_deei_pini_shɛŋa_mini_piibu Y? ditto
1020 Nana_Odame_Kusi Y? FIX/INVESTIGATE: newlines at start of refs seem to be trimmed in legacy but not with Parsoid
1011 Comfort_Doyoe_Cudjoe-Ghansah N Edge case extlink parsing diff. [https://example.org foo�bar] renders as an extlink in Parsoid but not with legacy. The char breaks it. Parsoid's behavior is preferable -- this is a won't fix.
1011 Bagabaga_College_of_Education N ditto
44033 List_of_South_Korean_films_of_1948 N Parsoid is processing a template which legacy isn't -- edge case, not a blocker.
1032 List_of_South_Korean_films_of_1990 N ditto
1032 List_of_South_Korean_films_of_1972 N ditto
2019 Broda_Shaggi N Edge cases in bad template uses in table cells. Parsoid renders 2 cells which legacy doesn't. Will get aligned when Parsoid's TableFixups code gets another overhaul. Not a blocker.
1016 Zynnell_Zuh N ditto
31019 List_of_Arrow_episodes N References list / Reference numbering diffs. Parsoid's behavior is better.
11035 Jɛŋkuno ? Cite error diffs and numbering diffs.
3024 United_States ? Parsoid auto-renders reference lists with ref-group attributes, but legacy emits an error message instead (whereas it auto-renders reference lists without ref-groups)
1032 The_Chicks_ni_deei_pini_shɛŋa_mini_piibu ? Parsoid auto-renders reference lists with ref-group attributes, but legacy emits an error message instead (whereas it auto-renders reference lists without ref-groups)
2017 Cristiano_Ronaldo ? Citation issues (errors + Parsoid's auto-rendering of reference lists with ref group attributes)
1044 Listed_parks_and_gardens_in_North_East_England ? Citation issues (errors + Parsoid's auto-rendering of reference lists with ref group attributes) + edge cases in td template uses in table cells.
1035 Ghana_Nu'_Zaa_Zuɣu_Rediyo_Adaka_Nima N Given this wikitext |-Okyeame Radio || || [[Bibiani,\nWNR]]" Parsoid parses that as a wikilink in a td-cell and later strips them all as invalid tr-attributes, but legacy parses the "WNR]]" on a new line as fostered content. WONT-FIX.
1032 List_of_awards_and_nominations_received_by_The_Chicks N ditto (page is a redirect)
1017 Riho_Yoshioka N Minor cite number formatting issue ("6.00 6.01 etc" vs "6.0 6.1 etc")
1012 Bayelsa_Medical_University N TC
1010 Luis_Suárez ? citation errors
2011 Adoxomyia_heminopla ? citation errors + TC
1010 Grade_II*_listed_buildings_in_High_Peak ? citation errors + TC
1007 Chovgan ? citation errors + TC
1006 Youssouf_Fofana_(footballer,_born_1999) ? citation errors + TC
1005 Elsie_Effah_Kaufmann_Foundation ? citation errors + TC
1005 Ato_Panford ? citation errors + TC
1005 Lira_University ? citation errors + TC
1005 Federico_Valverde ? citation errors + TC
1004 Wikipidia ? citation errors + TC
1004 Makerere_University_School_of_Public_Health ? citation errors + TC
1004 Wikipedia ? citation errors + TC
1004 List_of_religions_population ? citation errors + TC
1003 United_Arab_Emirates ? citation errors + TC
2036 Ama_Pomaa_Andoh N Visual diffing noise - not a real diff