User:DWalden (WMF)/Test2wiki k8s migration/Editing
Feature | Need testing? | Does it have dependencies? | Existing regression or smoke testing strategy? | Does the regression/smoke testing strategy cover the dependencies? | Can it be tested on test2wiki? | Feasible to make it testable on test2wiki? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
VisualEditor | Yes | Yes | Some browser tests | ??? | Yes | N/A |
WikiEditor | No | No | None | N/A | Yes | N/A |
TemplateData | No | No | None | N/A | Yes | N/A |
Citoid | Yes | Maybe? | None (probably?) | N/A | Yes | N/A |
DiscussionTools | Yes | Yes | None | N/A | Yes | N/A |
Notes
editConsidering User:DWalden (WMF)/Test2wiki k8s migration#Scope of change, please test:
- General editing of pages in VE
- Ensure that after saving changes and loading the editor again, the previously saved changes are visible
- Generating citations using Citoid
- Delivery of notifications when subscribed to a topic using DiscussionTools
Citoid features in VE depend on the backend Citoid, which in turns depends on being able to make external requests. Not sure if you want to count that as a dependency.
DiscussionTools depends on Echo, some job queue stuff, Parsoid/RESTBase, and some VE features.
VisualEditor
editWhat are the dependencies?
editDoes it use any external services?
edit- Parsoid
- Citoid
- RESTBase
Is there any back-end processing?
editNo(
Does it use external binaries?
editNo
Does it read or write files on the filesystem?
editNo
Is there a regression or smoke testing strategy?
editSome browser tests
Does it cover the dependencies mentioned above?
edit???
Can it be tested on test2wiki?
editYes
Is it feasible to make it testable on test2wiki?
editN/A
What features do not need testing on test2wiki?
editDefinitions
edit- test2wiki
- https://test2.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page. An environment hosted on production servers but with test data, so is appropriate for testing. The code it is running is updated every Tuesday.
- To find a list of extensions already installed on test2wiki, see https://test2.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Version.
- Need testing?
- Features may not need testing. For example, this might be because:
- it is not hosted on Production
- it is mainly a UI feature
- it is considered low-risk
- External services?
-
- Inside our ecosystem like database, APIs, Parsoid
- Outside our ecosystem like third-party APIs
- Back-end processing?
- Including DeferredUpdates, job queue. See How_to#Find_out_if_my_feature/extension_does_back-end_processing.
- External binaries?
- See How_to#Find_out_if_my_feature/extension_uses_external_binaries.
- Existing regression or smoke testing strategy?
- This could include:
- Selenium tests (see How_to#Find_pre-existing_Selenium_tests)
- API tests (see How_to#Find_pre-existing_API_tests).
- Documented test procedures
- Exploratory testing